Do Formula Brands Matter?
6:06 pm in Birth and Post Partum, Year 0 (newborn) to 1 by Mom at 38
We’ve been trying different formula brands for Baby J, because we’ve received free samples from formula companies (Similac and Enfamil).
I don’t know if all this switching around is a good idea for Baby J. I want to make up my mind and stick to one brand.
Baby J has been taking Enfamil the longest, because that was what he got at the hospital when the nurses fed him. At the hospital he was fed 2-oz-sized, ready-to-use nursing bottles. We’ve tried Enfamil powder and ready-to-use liquid. I’ve found that the ready liquid form seemed to make Baby J very gassy, and he would bear down hard and cry in discomfort. He did not get as gassy with the powder.
We tried the Similac Soy because we had a free sample. We noticed that the soy formulation seemed to greatly reduce Baby J’s gassiness and spit up, to the point where his feeding sessions became relaxed and quiet. However, he became constipated on it and would have a bowel movement only once every 3 days when he used to “go” once a day. He also seemed very uncomfortable when he was having a bowel movement. Then the pediatrician told us that all babies 1 year and older are supposed to drink cow’s milk, and if Baby J is not using his lactase (enzyme that breaks down lactose) because he’s drinking soy, then he may feel bloated and uncomfortable when the time comes to drink full fat cow’s milk. Kind of ruined my plan for going full soy for his feeding! (I also jumped the gun and bought a big can of Similac soy formula, which is now just sitting there as I debate whether to use it at all.)
Recently we signed up for a Costco membership, and bought their private label (i.e. “store brand”) formula called Kirkland Signatures. When I first opened the can, I didn’t like the texture of the powder. Compared with Enfamil powder, which was very fine, the Costco brand seemed coarser and appears to contain more moisture because the powdery granules clump together. I also didn’t like the way it smelled compared with the Enfamil brand. Granted, I don’t like how formulas smell in general, the Costco brand seemed a bit more pungent than the Enfamil brand. Baby J also seemed to spit up more on the Costco brand.
I was rueful that I’d be wasting a totally fine can of Costco formula (they sell the formula in 2 canister packs) and that I’d end up spending more money because I wanted to continue giving Baby J the Enfamil powder. I’m especially concerned about the amount of latent spit-up Baby J seemed to have with the Costco brand, meaning it takes him a while to spit up a large amount, which would be bad if I put Baby J back to sleep after feeding him. What if he ends up choking on the large amount of spit-up? My husband called me “rigid” for wanting to switch back to the Enfamil. I told him that I’m the one who feeds Baby J many times more than he does, and I observe how Baby J reacts to the formula. I’m pissed off at my husband for his lack of appreciation for these types of details and for calling me rigid.
So do formula brands matter? Well, this article says no, and advises us to, in fact, opt for store brands and be proud of the savings. However, my personal experience tells me that brands do matter to some babies whose digestive systems may be sensitive to the specific formulation, even when the FDA requires all formula brands to contain a certain amount of critical ingredients. If I could, I’d love to use the more cost-effective brand and save a pretty penny in the long run.
Today I was all ready to wrap Baby J up and walk to the grocery store to get myself an overpriced can of Enfamil… and wouldn’t you know it, Enfamil dropped off 2 sample canisters of their powder in our mailbox, because I had signed up at their website a few weeks ago.
(I still wrapped Baby J around me and walked to the grocery store, though, and bought myself a big bottle of cappucino protein drink and 3 big chocolate cookies. I finished 2 of the cookies by the time I got home.)
Image source: Costco
Recent Comments