(Unsolicited!) Parenting Advice
6:36 pm in Birth and Post Partum, Year 0 (newborn) to 1 by Mom at 38
When we send pictures to my parents and the in-laws, the mothers usually respond with unsolicited parenting advice. One told me not to pick up Baby J when he cries, to “train” him not to be spoilt. Another told us to start reading books to him.
With my mom, I can be blunt about not wanting to be told how to raise my child. With the in-law I don’t feel the same degree of latitude. Instead, I stew and tell off my husband.
“Tell your mom to stop with the unsolicited advice!” I’d huff and puff. “I’ve done my own research and read experts’ opinions and I will do what I feel is best!”
Recently I couldn’t hold back and wrote a looooooong email telling the in-law that I will be following the advice of board-certified medical doctors who have done scientific research involving thousands of parents and babies, and that I subscribe to Harvey Karp‘s and William Sears‘ opinions about newborn care and babywearing (that newborns up to 3 months can’t be “spoilt”) and that I don’t believe in letting Baby J “cry it out”. I also stated that many of today’s parenting approaches are really for the convenience of parents, and when I made a conscious decision to have Baby J, I also was prepared to adjust my lifestyle to care for Baby J.
Essentially, I was telling her off but disguised with analytical discourse.
Today a friend said that some people take it personally when their parenting advice is not heeded because they may see it “as a personal attack that they were wrong and did not do what was best for their baby.”
This is true and I want to remember this when I “gently” redirect unsolicited advice from people. See, at the beginning when Baby J was very sick, I was so distraught that I listened to everyone – and I mean – EVERYONE’s advice. There were many conflicting opinions even amongst the so called “professionals” and healthcare providers.
The result: I was a basketcase. I second-guessed everything I did, I felt paranoid that I was incompetent and would possibly not be able to help Baby J get healthier and stay alive. It was awful and I was awful (my behavior toward my husband).
Then I had a long talk with my friend Sharon, after emailing her about some of the anxiety I was experiencing as a new mom. She told me to “take back my power” and that I do know how to be Baby J’s mom, and that I do know what is best for him, and to listen to my gut. I felt more confident after that, and my perspective changed.
True to form, Baby J became a healthy and robust baby, gaining almost 3 pounds in 3 weeks by his 2 month check up. He’s probably double his birth weight of 6 pounds 6 ounces by now.
I think because of this experience, I became more defensive than normal when people shove advice in my face. Most are polite about it, but the parents/in-laws seem to be more bossy the way they “communicate”. Then I start seeing it as a personal attack to *me* as if I don’t know how to care for Baby J, and I get more upset than I should be.
Remembering what my friend said about other people feeling attacked reminds me to be more “understanding” of where people who shove their advice in my face are coming from, and I hope I can remember to respond in a loving way rather than wanting to bite their head off because I feel I’m being attacked.

Recent Comments